By David H. Stevens, CMB
Harry and Meghan will gift us with a royal baby, 3D printers will go mainstream, and the FIFA Women’s World Cup takes place this summer in France with Team USA as the defending champs. This new year even marks the 50th anniversary of the Apollo 11 mission, a great reminder as to how old this writer is.
Yes, 2019 will be an exciting year with expectations of changes ahead. But what changes might impact your business?
I reached out to superstars in our industry to ask their views. Here is the list of experts to whom I asked this question: “What are the 2-3 things you will be watching in 2019?”
Our All Star Lineup:
- Mark Zandi – Chief Economist at Moodys
- Frank Nothaft – Chief Economist as CoreLogic
- Jim Parrott – Former senior advisor on housing policy to President Obama, Nonresident Fellow at the Urban Institute, and owner of Falling Creek Advisors
- Barry Zigas – Director of Housing Policy at the Consumer Federation of America
- Gary Acosta – Co-Founder and CEO of NAHREP
- Susan Stewart – CEO of SWBC Mortgage and Vice Chairman of the MBA
- Bill Cosgrove – President and CEO of Union Home Mortgage and former MBA Chairman
- Barry Habib – Founder and CEO of MBS Highway
- David Lykken – Founder, Owner, & Managing Partner of TMS Advisors
- Byron Boston – President and CEO of Dynex Capital, Inc
- Andrew Rippert – CEO Global Mortgage Group, Arch Capital Group Ltd.
- Toni Moss – CEO and Founder of Americatalyst and Eurocatalyst
- Carol Galante – Donald Terner Distinguished Professor in Affordable Housing and Urban Policy, Faculty Director Terner School for Housing Innovation, University of California Berkeley. Former FHA Commissioner
Not surprisingly, there are many common elements to the perspectives of these renowned leaders in housing. Whether running mortgage, MI, or REIT companies, forecasting economic ramifications going forward, or leading in policy and strategic advisory roles, many of the views point to change and uncertainty in this dynamic environment. Let’s review some of the perspectives of this stellar group:
Leadership changes at the GSEs, FHFA:
- “In housing policy, leadership at FHFA is the biggest issue hanging over 2019 by a long shot,” stated Jim Parrott.
- “In the past quarter-century, 2019 will mark the first time that FHFA, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will all have new leadership at the helm,” observed Frank Nothaft.
Many are wondering what will happen to the GSEs under new leadership:
- “When will Mark Calabria be confirmed? And once confirmed, how will he balance his previously-professed desire to shrink the GSE footprint, versus attempting to maintain momentum in the economy for Trumps 2020 bid for re-election?” asked Andrew Rippert.
- “IMBs played a significant role during the housing crisis, responsibly delivering to the GSE’s as the playing field became more level,” stated Susan Stewart. “A reduction in products offered immediately limits access to credit for borrowers and is a direct hit to the IMB.”
- “Like most, I do expect efforts to constrict the GSE footprint through loan limits, restrictions on cash-out refinances, higher capital requirements leading to higher g-fees and tighter restrictions on pilots that could expand access,” said Barry Zigas.
- “At Dynex we believe government policy will drive returns. Hence we await changes given the changes at FHFA,” added Byron Boston
- “On FHFA and the GSEs, how does the Trump Administration policy affect the slowing housing market?” asked Bill Cosgrove.
- And on a related note, Jim Parrott observed: “The wildcard is personnel. Who’s running the show on these issues at Treasury and HUD in a year? This would be a bit uncertain in any administration, but it’s especially so in this one.”
On Rates, Volumes, and Margins:
What will rates do next year affects … everything?
- Frank Nothaft: “The Fed is expected to raise its federal funds rate 50-75 bps higher by the end of 2019. That means short-term rates will go up, affecting ARMs and HELOCs. Long-term rates will rise too, but not as much. It’s important to see how much higher rates go and their effect on originations.”
- Mark Zandi: “The key to the health of mortgage banking in 2019 is mortgage rates. If the 30-year fixed is much over 5 percent, it will be a tough year. Under 4.5 percent should be a good year assuming rates aren’t falling because we are headed into a recession. The mortgage banking industry should buckle in, if it hasn’t already.”
- Byron Boston: “I am watching the impact of larger macro factors on the US housing market. Will there be a larger global credit correction that ripples through multiple global markets from stocks, currencies, real estate, etc. On the one hand interest rates could stay lower but on the other hand credit may once again become an issue. This does not have to be a 2008 scenario. It can simply be a nasty correction that slows activity in the housing market.”
- Toni Moss expressed this concern: “The Trump economy has not lifted the middle class and under middle class. Jobs are insecure and further layoffs should be anticipated. Servicers should hope for the best but prepare for the worst.”
And what about margins?
- From Susan Stewarts view: “And lastly, margin compression. We keep watching as the industry continues to create new business models including various M&A options. For carefully managed companies, 2019 should be a year of growth opportunities.”
- David Lykken is looking to see this: “There is a very real potential for an unusually large number of IMB’s being forced to close their doors for three primary reasons. Continued margin compression due to failure to address the elephant in the room, MLO compensation. Failure to focus on reducing operating costs due to outdated and inefficient business processes. And finally an intensely competitive landscape where those that take care of 1&2 above will do better than those that haven’t.”
- Bill Cosgrove states it simply: “Rate compression, where do we go from here?”
There was a lot on the growth of Mortgage Brokers and MLO Strategies for success.
- As Gary Acosta asked: “Will Mortgage Brokers gain substantial market share?”
- David Lykken: “I believe there is solid evidence that there will be a significant resurgence of the wholesale/broker channel that could grow to eclipse previous highs.” He adds, “We are already seeing evidence of the beginning of a migration of top MLO’s who are being told that their compensation is too high, leaving where they can go out on their own. Many believe they will be better on their own than having their future tied to a losing IMB operation.” David adds that he has been “advising his clients to start a wholesale origination operation so that MLO’s who leave will at least have the option to broker back to them.”
- Barry Habib suggested: “The originator needs to transition from a salesperson to a consultant.” He suggests more time be spent on understanding the total borrowers profile. “a deeper look at the examination of their overall debt picture” will help identify other ways to the use the mortgage as a financial planning tool. He adds, “loans should be looked at two at a time, not just the current loan but how does it fit into the next loan they will need.”
Finally, varied thoughts in technology, FHA, and opportunity to innovate:
- “We are focused on maximizing our investment in technology. The current cost to originate is not sustainable and the effective use of technology to reduce cost without sacrificing quality appears to be our best hope. Ultimately providing an easier process for the borrower should create a great upside for lenders,” said Susan Stewart
- Bill Cosgrove stated a similar view: “Technology and the level of consumer acquisition – seeing beyond the horizon. What does the next generation look like and how do you compete and win?”
- Jim Parrott: “Another area to keep on eye on is whether the FHA cleans up its false claims act mess because the ripple effect could be significant either way. If it does, look for some larger lenders to ease their way back in”. He adds a note of caution, “And if it doesn’t look for FHA and Ginnie to become increasingly anxious about their counterparty risk as the market tightens.”
- Barry Zigas added: “Whether and how far FHA will be able to reverse its decades long decline in infrastructure capacity, finalize its taxonomy and loan level certification, and diversify its lender base to include more regulated and deeply capitalized lenders to serve first time and low wealth borrowers.”
- Carol Galante agreed, adding: “Will policy makers finally give FHA the funding needed for a modern infrastructure to support its essential functions and while at it make reforms to ensure its ability to serve all those who depend on them.”
Clearly these leaders had a lot more to say which we hope to cover in more in depth discussions with many of them in the weeks ahead. But questions ranged from the New Democratic leadership in the House of Representatives and potentials for bipartisan GSE reform, new programs for borrowers such as shared appreciation and more to help todays buyer connect with housing, pressure on rental housing, and critical points about adjusting to increased risk of major storm implications to coastal areas. We share a wonderful industry, but one that changes and presents all of those involved with challenges … and opportunities. The key point I take away from this thoughtful input is the need to see the future and adapt. Here’s to a successful 2019 for all of you!
David H. Stevens, CMB, is housing policy expert, former CEO Mortgage Bankers Association, and former Assistant Secretary of Housing and FHA Commissioner. Find more of his posts at http://www.davidhstevens.com